IEC_62305-1_237_RVC.pdf

81/237/RVCRESULT OF VOTING ON CDVProject number:IEC 62305-1,Ed.1Reference number of the CDV81/216/CDVIEC/TC or SCTC 81Date of circulation2003-12-19Title of the TC or SC concernedLightning protectionTitle of the committee draft:IEC 62305-1,Ed.1:Protection against lightning-Part 1:General principlesThe above-mentioned document was distributed to National Committees with a request that voting take place for approvalfor circulation as an FDIS(or publication as a Technical Specification or Report)Voting resultssee printout attachedComments received see annex 1)In the case that the approval criteria for acceptance have been met,aThe committee draft for vote(CDV)will be registered as an FDIS by(date)2004-12bThe draft technical report(DTR)will be published as a Technical ReportThe draft technical specification(DTS)will be published as a Technical Specificationby(date).DECISION OF THE CHAIRMAN(in cooperation with the secretariat),in the case that the approval criteria for acceptancehave not been metcA revised committee draft for vote(CDV)will be distributed by(date).dA revised committee draft(CD)will be distributed by(date).NOTE In the case of a proposal c or d made by the chairman,P-members objecting to such a proposal shall inform theCentral Office with copy to the secretary in writing within 2 months of the circulation of this compilation(see ISO/IECDirectives,Part 1,2.6.5).The comments will be discussed at the next meeting of the TC/SC on(date)2004-10Name or signature of the SecretaryG.B.Lo PiparoName or signature of the ChairmanC.BouquegneauFORM RVC(IEC)2002-03-201)to be collated on Form Comments and annexed.2 81/237/RVCANNEX AResult of Voting on CDV-Document 81/216/CDVProject:IEC 62305-1 Ed.1IEC 62305-1,Ed.1:Protection against lightning-Part 1:General principlesCirculation Date:2003-05-09Closing Date:2003-10-10CountryStatusReceivedVoteCommentsAustriaP2003-10-08Y-BelgiumP2003-09-02Y-ChinaP2003-09-29YYDenmarkP2003-10-02YYFranceP2003-09-16YYGermanyP2003-10-08NYGreeceP2003-09-10Y-HungaryO2003-10-07A-IrelandO2003-10-06Y-ItalyP2003-10-09Y-JapanP2003-10-10YYKorea(Rep.of)P2003-10-09YYLuxemburgP2003-10-07Y-MexicoO2003-10-10A-NetherlandsP2003-10-07Y-NorwayP2003-10-09Y-PolandP2003-10-10YYPortugalP2003-10-09YYRomaniaO2003-09-08Y-Russian Fed.P2003-10-10Y-South AfricaP2003-10-10Y-SpainP2003-09-24Y-SwedenP2003-10-09A-SwitzerlandP2003-08-27Y-U.S.A.P2003-10-10YYUnited KingdomP2003-10-01Y-Approval CriteriaResultP-members voting:21P-members in favour:20=95%=67%APPROVEDTotal votes cast:23Total against:1=4%=25%APPROVEDFinal Decision:APPROVEDNOTES1.Vote:Does the National Committee agree to the circulation of the draft as a FDIS:Y=In favour;N=Against;A=Abstention.2.Only votes received before the closing date are counted in determining the decision.Late Votes:(0).3.Abstentions are not taken into account when totalizing the votes.4.P-members not voting:Australia;Serbia&Montenegro;(2).3 81/237/RVCNOTE Comments will be considered by WG 8 its next meeting in July 2004.The results will be circulated to NCs before the TC 81 meeting(Seoul 2004-10).Annex BDateDocument2003-12-1981/216/CDVNationalCommitteeClause/SubclauseParagraphFigure/TableType ofcomment(General/Technical/Editorial)COMMENTSProposed changeOBSERVATIONS OF THE SECRETARIATon each comment submittedCN1 ScopePar.3,line3te“HV transmission line”should beoutside this standardDEGeneralAll standards IEC 62305-1 throughoutIEC 62305-5 are strongly correlatedtogether.Therefore their content shall becoordinated and the publication date ofthe same status(CD,CVD,)should besynchronised in time.Otherwise it will bevery difficult to discuss and to commentthem successfully.DEGeneralTechnicalFundamentally it has to be stated,thatthere are two different completeprotection systems for structures:a)62305-3 describes a systemcalled“LPS”to protect againstPHYSICAL DAMAGE TOSTRUCTURES AND LIFE HAZARDoffering a bundle of definedprotection measuresb)62305-4 describes a systemcalled“LPM”to protect electricaland electronic systems withinstructures.The offered severalprotection measures shall becombined to a complete tailoredLPM system.This philosophy has to be describedclearly in 62305-1 and shall be followedconsequently in the other parts.DK14Figure 2and 3EA strange triangle can be seen just abovethe floor in both figuresRemove or explain the meaning of thistriangleDK15GeneralEIEC uses decimal comma,but in severalplaces the decimal point has been used,e.g.tableC.2,C.3,D.1 and D.2Use decimal comma 4 81/237/RVCNationalCommitteeClause/SubclauseParagraphFigure/TableType ofcomment(General/Technical/Editorial)COMMENTSProposed changeOBSERVATIONS OF THE SECRETARIATon each comment submittedKR 1Add the exceptional caseThe following cases are outside theobject of this standard;Railway system;Vehicles,Underground Explosives manufacturingbuildings and magazines;Electric generating,transmission,and distribution systemsPLGeneralThe document should be completed withthe recommendations common for part 3and part 4 of IEC 623