自白任意性规则研究.pdf

!#!$%&()*+,-.(/01!23456789:;?A!B;CDEF#GHIJKLMN5OPQ!RSTU;$GVWX?YZIJR_5ab#$%&cdefghijk5l$%mn$%&KNopqr!stuvjwx5!yw;z|5?H?5!?J?5?_?I?;?d?#&j?N?2?c:?_?!?_5?c?Q5B#?“2w2kficRfl?bI!j?;5?H”?5!?5#cyJ?_?_,!i?5?;BT;?0pN5?!c?_SI!i?5?;?B?!jop?5?zc#?:?KLMN5?!?;?_?;?_?E?RN?_?5(?E?N?5()%?w?&*!?!#$?#?!#S$#%?w?+#+!#$%&()ZI BAI REN YI XING GUI ZE YAN JIU&%&?KLMN!P,?_Qc?(!)*;+!ayJ?_,?-.5/0#1!j%?w?&23455c6789?:cSI?;?50V?5?A#xB!2CD!y?5E?FYG fl?baH-.!IJKQL?,M2CD!y#3U5EqHrst!u?_vIJRUw!c/x?#IJ5R_c?ay!IJ5;+Rzc?!|Q?_?;+5?cIJ2?v?!?_N2?cIJ?#?f!mn3U?IJRUw?g5-.?z?!?N?:|QcIJ?VW?B5?c?fKQ?f%?oR&#!#!#$%&()+!+!#!$%&()*+,-./!000000000!#$%&()*+!,!-#./012&$%!,!3#4#5.&6789:;?4)ABCD?:.E!#%,!1#!$%&()*+23456!#00000000!#FG)EHI#012?&JK4LM!#,!-#FG)EHI#012?&KN;?&RS#T)4UV!&,!=#WXHYZQ.#012&!&%,!#_!&(,!7#!$%&()*+89:;!#000000000!#012?&U)ab!,!-#012?&cdab!),!3#012?&abef4gh!)$,$#$!#$%&()ZI BAI REN YI XING GUI ZE YAN JIU!?!)00000000000!#ijk?!)*,!-#elmn?!*%,!A#!BC$%&(+DE=!%(000000000!#opqr&s!($,!-#ot012uv&wxyz!(#,!3#|#012&A!(),!=#+t?Ak?!(,!F#!$%&()*4GHIJKL!#0000000!#H?)U?&*+4?!,!-#%?7AB&4)?&CD!(,!3#H?T#012?&?2;?&?!#,!#_!#),MNOPQR!#*#0000000000000000000!#?!#*#,!-#?!#*!,!3#)?!#*&,!=#?!#*,!#S?!#%$,$!$!#!#$%&()*+,!#$%&!()*+,-./0)12,-./3456789:;?ABCDEFGHIJ#KLM#$%NOP=$!Q=!ROSTUVW%XYW78NOPZ!R./_FW_aNbcdefgh6ijNI5klm!n.N#$%,opq789:;=Nrstuvw!gx6yz|!)0U?!?vQ=N?%?%R?%?I?ef0?-?Frs!?q?789:;=N?,?I?j?J?!?y?!?.rsDN!q789:;=“-?N?fi!flqn.#$%?NFGH?&!&!#%$%&()*)!)+,-.#$/-!0%&1!#$%&()ZI BAI REN YI XING GUI ZE YAN JIU!#!$%&()*+,-./#*2345%6789:;?)ABC!DE=?)3FGAHIJ453KL!MNO:;PQR3STUV!MNWX;YQR3STZ$!#_3a?b;cde*2453fg?UV$h/i!jklm)*n3;Y*opAq5rBstuvw#Ix$D;2y!zc!SIx3|3?!J?Ix:F35?b3?UH!?b?Ix?Z!?Ix?Z?;P?S?3?!SU?3a?M9!%#$%&()*+?nIx3?c?Ix?Z3fg?UVf!FHIx3|!*2n?c!;c!“;Pb;3fifl|sRk3sR*oS#Ix$:sR3?!sRk3)Z5)!k?*,-.#%/-!0!1!#!#$%&()*+,R3fi?(”y?)?Ix?#I?I?3?*Ijx$!D?SIx?C?3!?|?3#Ix$?:?,?)?#Ix$3?|?3U?Efi?3AHqs?!D;?3Ix?Hn?)?3#Ix$!M?IxAn?3?!?3?C!?o?)3?!Sk%k%k%?FHIx3de?Ak()!*op?!?Ix+*+,-./0+,:#|?$|%&#Ix!c(-)(*+,-3?S.;?I/?,30I?,:(*-e!123-e+345fl67+3453fi.8?c!Ix?()9?q)(*3,-?3SI?s:3;fiIx:#|?$|%&#|?3Ix?3,-?3&0fl:AB30$|?3IxC(SH?3,-?3D;IxZES3c$|?3Ix$FG%!$|3Ixc()Hl?S,-?30!IJ?SK,-?30?Ix3LMk*o1 2 3 4,2565+7 8 9,?#NOP)QIx?;E:-%I!?:Rd?Ix1s?;Efi!I?fiL?wS:-?T?!qU%V5&%&!k.WX*QyG?YZY(”y?)!_#/a?!0!&1bc%def(IxZ/Tk(Z?g%h)!i(?j?)#!/0)k!0&#1!#$%&()ZI BAI REN YI XING GUI ZE YAN JIU!Ixl?m?,Hno%Ip!=s%?Ix$!#|3Ix?$|3IxqqUs:H?3fi!qUs:H?3fi?I+:2 3 0/0+,:*orst(,$|?k?”!#|?k?”?)?u!k!()$/(v?7?()0)w0!xZIx?Dfl&s:Hfio3?!fi!y5DEficzS:)|M3?,!8y5DEfic?3!rcqULL?!k?)SIx3?;E?3?A?!SIx3?8?:?b;3?!A?*2nSIx3|8:$|?#|%&#$|?!Ixc(?I?3,-?1?I?o?3fi?;LC0?A?,-3?!Rt?A?)?J+?p%?,flo?J+?,?zI?o?3!OcSs:?3#0$!?scIx8)?n?#|?!Ixc?I?,-?3Dfl?9&3fi=?Rt?A?)?Jflo?J?y-3!?cIxq?!A)?!?3c$|(?lm)0%w0!Z)!kj?,-.#%/-!0%)1!#!#$%&()*+,?(z?0S)9?s:3?“3C!=?01KIx!8?0%!(w3Z!AcK,HIJ?3e?t!s?($!wcFH)9?;fi?;fi3(M3Z 9,2,0/,D;?)gq!zc?ESIx3;|(k?lm)0$w0!Z#?Ix!L?)?i3)9?;fi$:*oS?#?)9?3FHI?,-3fi!?L?”?S)9?IxtA?3)?%?3?!DB3s?c;E?!?8c;P)?IJ?L?(3$.T!?)0%&wFHS)9?s:3?J30$xZ#)9y-?A)?%)?T?3,-e?3Ix$JL!k?lm)?3Ixc()9?S,-?3fi!?38cffi3$|!1?:&Ix7I?fi!?SKPkIx|3?)?!jp?!Ixc;Py?%?“?nq?qT3?zc!?&!y5c$|rc#|!0,&!(?lm)0%!(wcSIx3(M?3Z,H?%?flo?3Ix!A?s?3k?Bflo?3Ix!?qqUL?1K,IIJ?3Ix!?s?(s5cz)9?A?3Ix!?IxcSq?s:3;(t!s?)9?:-f?3Ix!?S?l3,-I:-346?fl(k?lm)?)!k)?*,-.#/-!0!#$1!#$%&()ZI BAI REN YI XING GUI ZE YAN JIU-?cIx?3?“flo!Ix3M9w?U?AHS,-?30r3()*?!+?0 8 3+7.,(,#Ixc()9?I?)(*,-?3Dflq?9&?03e?$!q!?9,-?(,-?9?3?!?)?3,-?t%t%?#LCq#LC39?*D,-?J?9,-?T!r?7!?.%/?3Ix?9cES,-?9?3fi!SHMz/?D,-?3fi!SHIx31s0123HqU7?s:3?%73?%04?o?3?cIx3569?:*oG#?Ix3FG7c)9?Sq,-?30!3Hq03?!1s12Ix3$D8?c?Ix?Z53UV.T!A5?!jk:*o?Ix&?8?3Ix7?8?T3Ix!#?o?DE&c:?|3Ak!9?NO?:?c?7l;=?Ak3?)Q+5 9 8 0/7 9 .*+4 7,!:-?7?(#AB!?&!#?0 8 3+7.!A,1 B 0 2.,C.!D 0 E E.7/7.B;!()%FG 4 H H E.3.,!(#!9 )!*CwIDE|r(?lm)FGC?9)!k?*,-.#$/-!0%&1DE|r(?lm)FGC?9)!k?*,-.#$/-!0%Yqc3Ix3?ADB89?3c!?7,-?3Ixs:d?3S?!?3ef3AH/?IxJ!?9?3Ix?Z3Ix?L?&J!D J.*7 0 3 0,9 EK 7+C./:,1 B 9 E 4 9 0 B.G 4 2 L!A M-+7 2N,0 B.7/0 LK 7./!()!K O&);&(6bg(?k7k3)?q)!k)?*,-.!()/-!0%(1bc%def(IxZ/Tk(Z?g%h)!i(?j?)#!/0)k!0&#1hij(?()%5UV)!iklm?Y(?()K5)!n,-.!()$/-!0Yqc?,3:-;fi?G3#Ix$8cADPn?;EG(!Ixs:?+!,?t3?,!A?l?q?)9?+D J.:C C 4/.2+7P.-.,2 9,89(,3c!,-?%)9?,3IxMNcFHI?3,-?!?js%?KR:qU,-?%)9?!floR:,-?%)9?KQR,-?T,-?3!s?Ix3?t+,?3ef?DC?,-e?c,-?%)9?!S,-?3tu?qIxMef?,-?Ds?cIx(7qU(?3?v(!?8c?sw?)/?Ix3?xyzA?:3*oG!D#snv?flqU?|3?$!+%,?SL?#Ix?c?3!Ixc?3:-($zc!JH,-?%)9?7:?:?3:,F?!;LC!W?Ix3?LM?!?c?A?%y;e?!RLM?Ix3?*.;LC!A)?!)9?LMV?X*3Ix!?&?,&3Ix?!?Ix3?L?u,!q;!IxA?:?s:3ef?%DC?7?SsL?%?A?*q&)&!?(?3IJ)!k)?*,-.#!/-!0!J1 2 0 0+,!?9 2/I+7 J S,C 6!#$!K#%6!#!#$%&()*+,?!?/?Ix3?yz7K)?IxLM?IxRs?%8?A?!DUE?c;P?3UPLC!?=?3?)?cA,-?%)9?3IxcI/?,3,%-./01&$%A?lm)*!?+T+E 4,9 7 0,./!8q?I/?,c;P?3)+?Ak!#Ix3:?7?S?A;?!qAH;PIx?Ij?-?M9$!?!ST?)Q?;?g8?3!?#?+U,+I 0,8,%?+S,.E E 0.,C.,?I/$8:*o?#?(A#?1y?Ix%4$8?c!3?!?c(,-?%)9?3:-;fi?D,HI/!H?3?3H,-?%)9?9;fi,-?!?c?!3sH?IxMNs:?!DcIx?(s:(M3U?9?A*n!:*o?Ix?Z3|fi?#A?:?!O:UH)Hl?IJ?,3Ix+=0:-3fi,!s:(M*?fls:K?3?;!s5c?!?ssL?$#?!DB3?8?cI/?!I/?c,-?%)9?Ix/?(?3fgw?!?!?,-?%)9?3I/?&(&!#*.+7 8.R 6*+E.!D J.:3.7 0 C 9,G L/.3+-*7 0 3 0,9 E Q 4/0 C.!?9 2/I+7 JK 4 V WE 0/J 0,8*+3 H 9,L S,