IEC_81-237eb-RVC.pdf

81/237B/RVCRESULT OF VOTING ON CDV Project number:IEC 62305-1,Ed.1 Reference number of the CDV 81/216/CDV IEC/TC or SC TC 81 Date of circulation 2004-08-27 Title of the TC or SC concerned Lightning protection Title of the committee draft:IEC 62305-1,Ed.1:Protection against lightning Part 1:General principles The above-mentioned document was distributed to National Committees with a request that voting take place for approval for circulation as an FDIS(or publication as a Technical Specification or Report)Voting results see printout attached Comments received see annex 1)In the case that the approval criteria for acceptance have been met,a The committee draft for vote(CDV)will be registered as an FDIS by(date)2004-12 b The draft technical report(DTR)will be published as a Technical Report The draft technical specification(DTS)will be published as a Technical Specification by(date).DECISION OF THE CHAIRMAN(in cooperation with the secretariat),in the case that the approval criteria for acceptance have not been met c A revised committee draft for vote(CDV)will be distributed by(date).d A revised committee draft(CD)will be distributed by(date).NOTE In the case of a proposal c or d made by the chairman,P-members objecting to such a proposal shall inform the Central Office with copy to the secretary in writing within 2 months of the circulation of this compilation(see ISO/IEC Directives,Part 1,2.6.5).The comments will be discussed at the next meeting of the on(date)Name or signature of the Secretary G.B.Lo Piparo Name or signature of the Chairman C.Bouquegneau This document cancels and replaces document 81/237A/RVC.FORM RVC(IEC)2002-03-20 2 81/237B/RVC ANNEX A Result of Voting on CDV-Document 81/216/CDV Project:IEC 62305-1 Ed.1 IEC 62305-1,Ed.1:Protection against lightning-Part 1:General principles Circulation Date:2003-05-09 Closing Date:2003-10-10 Country Status Received Vote Comments Austria P 2003-10-08 Y-Belgium P 2003-09-02 Y-China P 2003-09-29 Y Y Denmark P 2003-10-02 Y Y France P 2003-09-16 Y Y Germany P 2003-10-08 N Y Greece P 2003-09-10 Y-Hungary O 2003-10-07 A-Ireland O 2003-10-06 Y-Italy P 2003-10-09 Y-Japan P 2003-10-10 Y Y Korea(Rep.of)P 2003-10-09 Y Y Luxemburg P 2003-10-07 Y-Mexico O 2003-10-10 A-Netherlands P 2003-10-07 Y-Norway P 2003-10-09 Y-Poland P 2003-10-10 Y Y Portugal P 2003-10-09 Y Y Romania O 2003-09-08 Y-Russian Fed.P 2003-10-10 Y-South Africa P 2003-10-10 Y-Spain P 2003-09-24 Y-Sweden P 2003-10-09 A-Switzerland P 2003-08-27 Y-U.S.A.P 2003-10-10 Y Y United Kingdom P 2003-10-01 Y-Approval Criteria Result P-members voting:21 P-members in favour:20=95%=67%APPROVED Total votes cast:23 Total against:1=4%=25%APPROVED Final Decision:APPROVED NOTES 1.Vote:Does the National Committee agree to the circulation of the draft as a FDIS:Y=In favour;N=Against;A=Abstention.2.Only votes received before the closing date are counted in determining the decision.Late Votes:(0).3.Abstentions are not taken into account when totalizing the votes.4.P-members not voting:Australia;Serbia&Montenegro;(2).3 81/237B/RVC Annex B NOTE Comments were considered by WG 8 at its meeting in July 2004.Date Document 2004-08-27 81/216/CDV National Committee Clause/Subclause Paragraph Figure/Table Type of comment(General/Technical/Editorial)COMMENTS Proposed change OBSERVATIONS OF THE SECRETARIAT on each comment submitted CN 1 1 Scope Par.3,line3 te “HV transmission line”should be outside this standard Piping,power and telecommunication lines not connected to a structure are outside of the object of this standard DE 1 General All standards IEC 62305-1 throughout IEC 62305-5 are strongly correlated together.Therefore their content shall be coordinated and the publication date of the same status(CD,CVD,)should be synchronised in time.Otherwise it will be very difficult to discuss and to comment them successfully.Yet done.See Programme of Work of TC 81.DE 2 General Technical Fundamentally it has to be stated,that there are two different complete protection systems for structures:a)62305-3 describes a system called“LPS”to protect against PHYSICAL DAMAGE TO STRUCTURES AND LIFE HAZARD offering a bundle of defined protection measures b)62305-4 describes a system called“LPM”to protect electrical and electronic systems within structures.The offered several protection measures shall be combined to a complete tailored LPM system.This philosophy has to be described clearly in 62305-1 and shall be followed consequently in the other parts.Agreed.IEC 62305-1 follows yet this philosophy.DK14 Figure 2 and 3 E A strange triangle can be seen just above the floor in both figures Remove or explain the meaning of this triangle Agreed.It is the symbol of ground floor DK15 General E IEC uses decimal comma,but in several places the decimal point has been used,e.g.tableC.2,C.3,D.1 and D.2 Use decimal comma Agreed.4 81/237B/RVC National Committee Clause/Subclause Paragraph Figure/Table Type of comment(General/Technical/Editorial)COMMENTS Proposed change O